In the movie Earth Mama (2023), a young woman named Gia struggles with life while pregnant and fighting to regain custody of her older children. The film portrays Gia’s challenges as a troubled young woman, capturing her efforts to cope with a demanding reality. While the details of her past are not fully provided, the film hints that her history significantly shapes her future choices and actions. The themes woven through Gia’s story include a deep mistrust of social services, miscommunication between social workers and families, substance misuse, and the internal struggle between physical and mental well-being. This film is particularly valuable in depicting the complicated stigmas regarding social services that exist in society. Too often, these relationships are presented as adversarial; however, Earth Mama reveals that this divide is far more nuanced. From my perspective, it's evident that Gia deeply loves her children, yet she struggles to establish the stability necessary for them all to thrive. This film is crucial for social work as it highlights the emotional landscape of mothers dealing with social services, revealing how they may feel about the system and their place within it.
One of the most significant aspects of this film for social workers is its portrayal of the relationship between families and social services. The film emphasises how many people enter the system carrying preconceptions, as they are rarely given a clear explanation of the system’s role and purpose. This lack of transparency often results in mistrust and strained relationships. A powerful line from the movie, “You get paid to sell kids,” spoken to a social worker, vividly illustrates the mistrust and lack of understanding Gia feels toward social services. While the film does not explicitly reveal Gia’s past, it is possible to infer that her mistrust may stem from previous negative experiences with the system. This sense of suspicion is expressed in her reactions to authority figures such as her caseworker or the police; her demeanour reflects not fear but a deeply rooted distrust. This lack of communication has led to a strained relationship, making it difficult for both sides to move forward in a productive way. Social workers, especially when working with individuals with past traumas, must take time to explain the system’s role and build a foundation of understanding and empathy.
A second theme that the film addresses is substance misuse, which becomes a central part of Gia’s journey. This is an issue frequently encountered in family and child social services, as addiction often plays a role in the decisions made around child protection and welfare. In Gia’s case, there appears to be an internal struggle between her love for her children and her fight against addiction. Throughout the film, she attends all of the recommended support groups and classes, yet the movie implies that a different approach - perhaps more individualised rather than group-based - might have been more effective for her. Allowing her a more private, focused space to express her feelings could have helped her connect more meaningfully with her own recovery journey. This highlights the importance for social workers to fully understand the complexities of clients’ situations, taking time to grasp the root of their challenges to suggest the most effective, personalised support plans.
In my view, Earth Mama successfully uses its characters to explore important social work themes in an accessible and impactful way. However, certain aspects of Gia’s character development feel somewhat underdeveloped. For instance, understanding more about Gia’s background - such as her relationship with her mother, her upbringing, or the father of her child - could have enhanced the storyline, providing more context from the outset. By exploring these elements, the audience might have connected with Gia’s experiences earlier in the film rather than feeling confused until the middle or end. The film effectively conveys the emotional and psychological strain involved in Gia’s circumstances, and this level of detail helps the audience empathise with her journey. For those in social services, this film serves as an important reminder of the lived realities of individuals beyond the system, encouraging a more humane and empathetic approach.
It's essential for social workers to maintain empathy, compassion, and patience in these challenging relationships. Earth Mama illustrates that while social workers may “clock out” at the end of the day, clients such as Gia continue living with these realities. Their day-to-day struggles do not pause, and as social workers, it's vital to remember that we are not simply providing a service but supporting people in navigating their lives.
📷Photo credit: Amazon.co.uk / Amazon.com